NDTV Analysis: No Arab support, Humas is tall – Donald Trump’s Gaza Scheme Harcate

NDTV Analysis: No Arab support, Humas is tall – Donald Trump’s Gaza Scheme Harcate




New Delhi:

US President Donald Trump stood at a podium at the White House. Israeli Prime Minister Benjamin Netanyahu, who shut down his gaze on Trump, the President made a proposal with Bravo, which would decide the fate of more than 2 million people in a circular area about 9,500 km away. President Trump announced, “America will capture the Gaza Strip, and we will work with it.” But his announcement failed to answer a big question: what about Hamas?

The Armed Palestinian group nominated a terrorist organization by the US, maintaining a stronghold in Gaza and ruled over Enclave since 2007. After the 7 October attack on Israel in 2023, Israelis launched a disastrous attack on Gaza, causing a devastating attack on Gaza. Deaths of over 50,000 and displacement of millions.

In his proposal, Trump did not give any details on how his administration would handle the implication of an American intervention in another country in Hamas or another country in the Middle East.

“We will be the owner and all on the site will be responsible for eliminating all dangerous unexplained bombs and other weapons on the site. Level the site and get rid of destroyed buildings.” Trump said.

Netanyahu stood next to Trump at the press conference, pleased.

Trump has placed an idea that has shocked international observers: the idea that the United States can “Gaza” after the war and resume its Palestinian population elsewhere in the Middle East. His remarks have strongly condemned Palestinian groups, Arab countries and international experts, who question their viability.

Hamas still stands

Hamas remains a force in Gaza. Despite the months of Israeli’s bombing and ground operations, Hamas has neither been abolished nor taken out of the enclave, for the purpose of destroying it. Its continuous presence complicates any proposal for the future of Gaza, which is from Trump or any other political leader.

Hamas controls the underground tunnel network, maintains military capacity, and affects the population. While Netanyahu vowed to destroy the group, this objective is far from feeling. Some analysts believe that it may take years to eradicate Hamas – if it is possible.

Trump has said that he does not want to fight to resume after the current ceasefire, yet his plan is not a realistic mechanism to remove Hamas from Gaza. Without a clear solution, their proposal immediately face practical obstacles:

The Israeli army has not completely eliminated the group after months of operation. It is unlikely that any Arab country will commit troops to fight Hamas on behalf of an American -led administration in Gaza. Trump’s previous foreign policy focuses on reducing US military partnership in the Middle East and withdrawing troops from Afghanistan, Syria and Iraq. The idea that he would commit to securing Gaza for years to the US armies is contrary to his own foreign policy stance.

There is no indication that Hamas will voluntarily control control or accept any external regime structure. Instead, it has vowed to displace displacement on Gaza and any foreign-planned rule. Hamas spokesperson Hazam Kasssem called Trump’s idea an attempt on “capture” and demanded an emergency Arab Summit to face any attempt to get Palestinians out of Gaza.

“Gaza is for his people, and they won’t leave,” Kasem said in a statement. “We ask Arab people and international organizations to take strong action to reject the Trump project.”

The armed group does not intend to renounce control or accept a settled disposal.

Arab status

The proposal to transfer 2 million inhabitants of Gaza of Trump to other Arab countries faces near-survival rejection. Egypt and Jordan, most often mentioned in previous discussions about potential refugee rehabilitation in both countries, has strongly opposed any such scheme.

Jordan is already home to a large Palestinian population. Its King Abdullah has repeatedly warned that any forced displacement of Gaza’s Palestinians will threaten their country’s stability. Many people from Jordan believe that re -starting Palestinians will lead Israel to capture West Bank.

Egyptian President Abdel Fattah al-Sisi has rejected the idea of ​​taking Ghazan refugees, fearing that it will not only show the safety threats related to Hamas in the Sinai Peninsula, but will also set an example for permanent displacement .

Even rich Gulf nations like Saudi Arabia and UAE have shown no desire to take a large number of displaced Palestinians. The Trump scheme has no regional support.

Saudi Arabia has already rejected Trump’s proposal. In recent months, Saudi officials have tied any generalization of relations with Israel for a concrete plan towards the Palestinian state. Trump’s plan refutes the goal that Saudi Arabia will join it.


Gaza Comment (T) Trump Gaza Strip (T) Benjamin Netanyahu (T) Benjamin Netanyahu News